HomeMy WebLinkAboutSun Valley Energy Inc., Agreement, 07.19.2022AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into as of this may of. 1 ,
2022, between the City of Fresno, a California municipal corporation (CITY), and S t
n
Valley Energy Inc., a Georgia S-Corporation (CONTRACTOR).
RECITALS
WHEREAS, the California Air Resources Board (GARB) issued a call for credits to
be pledged for sale in the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) credit clearance market
(CCM);
WHEREAS, the CITY pledged 5,513 LCFS credits;
WHEREAS, the CARB Executive Officer has determined that the CCM will occur
in 2022 to allow the five reporting entities the additional opportunity to meet their
obligation;
WHEREAS, the CONTRACTOR has sought to meet its obligations by purchasing
LCFS credits from the CITY;
WHEREAS, the parties seek an agreement to sell LCFS credits to the
CONTRACTOR; and
WHEREAS, this agreement is to be used by CARB to transfer credits from the
CITY to the CONTRACTOR as described herein.
AGREEMENT
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the above recitals which are contractual
in nature, the mutual promises herein contained, and for other good and valuable
consideration hereby acknowledged, the parties agree as follows:
CITY and CONTRACTOR mutually agree that the CITY shall sell to the
CONTRACTOR 779 CA LCFS credits at $110 per credit, for a total lump sum
payment of $85,690 to the CITY.
2. CITY and CONTRACTOR mutually agree that this agreement is subject to the
successful sales transaction and credit review. In the event the CONTRACTOR
is unable to pay the lump sum of $85,690 to the CITY, the CITY reserves the
right to reclaim the 779 CA LCFS credits. In the event CARB denies the credit
transaction, both parties shall be held harmless and this agreement shall
become null and void.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this agreement at Fresno,
California, the day and year first above written.
City of Fresno,
a Calif icipal corporation
Joe Vdr-of;Transportation
,
Direc
Fresno Area Express
Transportation Department
ATTEST:
Todd Stermer
City Clerk
BY:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Rina M. Gonzales
City Attorney
By: 1 �� v
auline Brickey Da e
Deputy City Attorne
Addresses:
CITY:
City of Fresno
Attention: Linda Taylor,
Administrative Manager
2223 G Street
Fresno, CA 93706-1675
Attachments:
1. Karbone Confirmation Notice
2. CARB CCM Notice
2
Sun Valley Energy Inc.,
S-Corporation
By.
Name: Al1tn /\14e.1,
Title:
By. 1rC
Name: L V'*
Title'.
(CFO/Secretary/Treasurer)
Contractor:
Sun Valley Energy Inc
dr
Karbone
KARBONE INC. CONFIRMATION NOTICE
675 Third Avenue, 30th Floor
New York, NY 10017 DATE: June 14th, 2022
ATTN: Allen Nivens FROM: Karbone Inc
Sun Valley Energy, Inc. PHONE: 781-389-0851
REF NO: CALCFS-1017-1011 FAX: 646-219-7168
On behalf of Karbone Inc, we are pleased to confirm the following Credit Clearance Market California Low Carbon Fuel
Standard (LCFS) credit transaction.
BUYER:
Sun Valley Energy, Inc.
PO Box 105
Gainesville, GA 30503
ATTN: Allen Nivens
EMAIL: anivens@sunvalleyenergy.net
CC: mnivens@sunvallyenergy.net
PHONE: 770-540-3935
SELLER:
City of Fresno Department of Transportation
2223 G Street
Fresno, CA 93706
ATTN: Orie Rubalcava
EMAIL: Orie.Rubalcava@fresno.gov
PHONE: 559-621-1537
PRODUCT: Credit Clearance Market CA LCFS Credits
DESCRIPTION AND TRANSACTION STRUCTURE:
Volume 779
Price $110 / Credit
PAYMENT: Payment will be made according to schedule outlined in mutually agreed and fully executed
Purchase and Sale Agreement (PSA).
DELIVERY: Immediate Delivery according to schedule outlined in mutually agreed and fully executed Purchase
and Sale Agreement (PSA).
OTHER TERMS: This transaction is subject to mutual contract and credit review
COMMISSION: $0.25 per credit, ie. $194.75, payable upon successful completion of PSA.
INVOICES: Invoices to be sent attention to: mnivens@sunvallyenergy.net
CONTACT: Ryan Melia, 781389 0851 // ryan.melia@karbone.com
The parties agree that Karbone's sole function with respect to the transaction is the introduction of the parties and that each is responsible for
evaluating the merits of the transaction and the counterparty. Karbone assumes no responsibility for the performance of the transaction or for the
financial condition of any party. Please verify for accuracy the details of this transaction and kindly bring to Karbone's attention any errors as soon
as possible.
2021 LCFS Compliance Information and Credit Clearance Market
Information
LCFS Compliance Reporting for 2021
The Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) achieved 99 percent compliance for the 2021
data year. A total of 497 entities reported under the LCFS program during 2021. Out of
those 497 entities, 60 generated deficits. The entities reporting high -carbon fuels
generated 18,848,688 deficits during this period. A total of 20,197,339 credits were
generated in the program over the same time period.
Summary of 2021 LCFS Compliance Reporting
Total number of entities
in 2021 under LCFS program
Total number of entities generating deficits during 2021
Total number of deficit generating entities that met their 2021 compliance
obligation
497
60
55
As reported in the 04 2021 Quarterly Data Summary, cumulatively through 2021, the
LCFS program has generated 97.7 million credits and 88.3 million deficits, for a net of
about 9.4 million credits banked in the program.
Credit Clearance Market
There were five parties that did not retire sufficient credits for 2021.
Name of the Regulated Party
Number of CCM
Deficits
Ag Environmental Products LLC
4
American Biodiesel, Inc. dba Community Fuels
510
Biodico Westside, LLC
206
Mutual Propane
127
Sun Valley Energy, Inc.
779
The LCFS includes a provision for holding a Credit Clearance Market (CCM) that
provides additional compliance flexibility to regulated entities who have not met their
previous year-end obligation.
On April 4, 2022, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) issued a call for credits to
be pledged for sale in the CCM. The following parties pledged a total of 24,467 credits
for sale in the 2021 CCM:
Name of the Regulated Party
Number of CCM Credits
City of Fresno Department of Transportation
5,513
City of Fullerton
500
City of Lodi Electric Utility
1,379
EVmatch, Inc.
5
Foothill Transit
695
Imperial Irrigation District
3,623
Long Beach Public Transportation
2,749
Neste US, Inc.
10,000
3
San Francisco Estuary Institute
The EO has determined that the CCM will occur in 2022 to allow the five reporting
entities the additional opportunity to meet its obligation. The CCM will be operational
from June 1 to July 31, 2022. During this period, this regulated party must acquire
credits pledged into the CCM from the parties listed above.
The maximum price set for credits to be sold in the 2021 CCM is $239.18 per credit.
Regulated parties that have pledged credits to sell into the CCM cannot reject an offer
to purchase pledged credits at the maximum price but may accept an offer to purchase
at a lower price if they prefer to do so.
If you have any questions regarding this document, please contact Cheryl Laskowski,
Transportation Fuels Branch Chief at (916) 621-9068 or via email
Cheryl. Laskowski(c-)-arb. ca.gov.
Program Background
The LCFS, a regulation to reduce the carbon intensity of fuels sold in California 20
percent by 2030, is one of the measures adopted by CARB, pursuant to Health and
Safety Code Sections 38500-38599 (AB 32) to reduce California's greenhouse gas
emissions. It is designed to help clean the air, protect the environment, and drive the
development of clean, low -carbon fuels.
The Credit Clearance Market provision increases market certainty regarding maximum
compliance costs, strengthens incentives to invest in and produce low -carbon fuels, and
reduces the probability of credit shortfalls and price spikes. For more information see
the LCFS Credit Clearance Market webpage.